random thoughts on railroad photography, railfanning, technology, and such

Entries in Williams (2)

Saturday
Jul302011

Our Best Trip Ever - Part 10 - Heading into the Unknown

(Continued from: Our Best Trip Ever - Part 9 - A Few Favorite Locations)

Day 5 - Part 2

Sailing into Uncharted Waters

After the shoot at CP Chalendar, I grew concerned, not so much about the distance we needed to travel today, but rather the uncertain condition of the roads and the general accessibility of the area that laid ahead in our travels along BNSF’s Seligman Subdivision. According to my original plans we were due to spend the day shooting the area around Eagle Nest and Double A. Since we were not even near Double A yet, I felt tense because that meant something must give in our schedule. I preferred it to be those areas we had visited before so we headed west on I-40 towards Williams, Arizona to try to get back on schedule.

It turns out that in my haste to depart Bellemont without refilling my propane tanks added value to the trip. Since we were going into the Kaibab National Forest, as we entered Williams, I topped off my diesel and fresh water tanks while also dumping our waste and grey water. All I needed now was propane.

Superior Propane, Inc. of Williams, Arizona.I saw from the freeway a propane distributor and I was up for giving the place a shot since I was tired of paying too much for propane from the truck stops along the way. Using dead reckoning and our GPS as the map we found the dealer that I saw from the freeway. The propane dealer was Superior Propane, Inc.

As a nice salesman refilled our tanks, he and I struck up a conversation. I preceded to explain our trip and our adventures thus far and asked for his knowledge of the area near Double A. Pulling a map from the cab of the truck he clued me in on what the road conditions were like and what to expect where. He even went so far as to offer additional railroad related shooting opportunities to be found near Seligman and Pica, further on in our trip.

Armed with this new, and locally confirmed, information, I felt easier about our plans and how successful we should be. I left a few business cards with the folks at Superior Propane and encouraged them to check my web site in a few months to see the result of our chase.  As we waved goodbye, we departed and headed north out of Williams.

For the next two days or so we would be visiting portions of the Seligman Subdivision that I have never chased before. This was the heart of our trip - the new, the uncharted, the unknown.

Using the map shown below, you can see that my original plans called for accessing Eagle Nest from a road heading north out of Ash Fork, Arizona - seen in yellow dashes. This route was gleaned from analysis of Google Maps and railfan reports. However, now that I knew the local road conditions I was able to maximize my travels in the Kaibab National Forest along the BNSF tracks. The route we actually traversed over two days in the forest are shown in red. This afforded a couple of other locations that I had resigned myself not being able to visit - all thanks to the folks at the Superior Propane.

CLICK FOR LARGER IMAGE - Actual route taken along the Crookton Cut-Off shown in RED thanks to information from the folks at Superior Propane. My original intended route is shown in yellow dashes. 

Shots from the Crookton Cut-Off

The road which lead us into the Crookton Cut-Off region was extremely smooth and wide for a gravel road. It was obvious this road was well maintained and it allowed us to make quick work of the distance that we needed to cover. In short order we found ourselves along side the BNSF transcon once again. The site was east of CP East DoubleA. (Pronounced as and spelled like “Double A” for most but “DoubleA” for the railroad.)

BNSF 4382 West 1 - BNSF 4382 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4367 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and BNSF 7673 (GE ES44DC) head up a westbound manifest consist seen here rounding a curve near East DoubleA on BNSF’s Crookton Cut-Off.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com

After a few quick shots, I took some time to look around. The land was amazing and not at all what I thought a “forest” would be like. The colors of the geology and foliage are surreal and vivid - a photographers dream.

BNSF 4382 West 2 - BNSF 4382 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4367 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and BNSF 7673 (GE ES44DC) head up a westbound manifest consist seen here rounding a curve near East DoubleA on BNSF’s Crookton Cut-Off.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com

BNSF 976 East 1 - BNSF 976 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4788 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and BNSF 5228 (GE DASH 9-44CW) give all they’ve got to muscle this eastbound manifest train upgrade and through the curves of the BNSF’s transcon line in Arizona. Seen here leaving CP West DoubleA.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Debra Parra, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 976 East 2 - BNSF 976 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4788 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and BNSF 5228 (GE DASH 9-44CW) give all they’ve got to muscle this eastbound manifest train upgrade and through the curves of the BNSF’s transcon line in Arizona. Seen here leaving CP West DoubleA.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 976 East 3 - BNSF 976 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4788 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and BNSF 5228 (GE DASH 9-44CW) give all they’ve got to muscle this eastbound manifest train upgrade and through the curves of the BNSF’s transcon line in Arizona. Seen here leaving CP West DoubleA.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

CP West DoubleA, View From the East
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

The one aspect of the line that I noted was how the line was graded and built. Being built rather recently, (the line was built in 1960 which is recent in historical railroad terms), the construction involved making ample use of fills and cuts with the help from heavy machinery that wasn’t available during the construction of most rail lines built a century prior. This fact tends to make chasing the line a tad bit challenging because you can find yourself 100 feet above the line one minute and two hundred feet below it the next minute. It does afford some amazing vistas though. Looking through the photos I took on the cut-off, you’d be hard press to find one without a cut or a fill in the shot.

One control point that I wanted to visit, if possible, was CP West DoubleA. I had seen photos of the location before and I was always drawn to the look and feel of it. The control point consists of a single crossover paired with a small siding and it is situated at the end of a deep cut.

Heeding the numerous “No Trespassing” signs posted along the BNSF right-of-way we searched for and found a vantage point on the east end of the control point. We decided to break for lunch and set-up to wait for some traffic. While we were waiting we saw the signals, both eastbound and westbound become favorable for us.

When I could hear the trains approach I went closer to the tracks and waited. Deb snapped this shot of me listening to discern which train would arrive first:

Waiting for the Shot
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Debra Parra & Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

The eastbound came through first. It was a doublestack intermodal (Deb took the second shot shown below):

BNSF 7321 East 1 - BNSF 7321 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7535 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7247 (GE ES44DC), and BNSF 4991 (GE DASH 9-44CW) enter the OS at West DoubleA with their eastbound intermodal consist prior to a westbound also cleared through West DoubleA on BNSF’s Crookton Cut-Off.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 7321 East 2 - BNSF 7321 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7535 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7247 (GE ES44DC), and BNSF 4991 (GE DASH 9-44CW) enter the OS at West DoubleA with their eastbound intermodal consist prior to a westbound also cleared through West DoubleA on BNSF’s Crookton Cut-Off.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Debra Parra, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 7321 East 3 - BNSF 7321 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7535 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7247 (GE ES44DC), and BNSF 4991 (GE DASH 9-44CW) hustle an eastbound intermodal consist through CP West DoubleA on BNSF’s Crookton Cut-Off.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

While I repositioned myself for another angle, the westbound blew by and caught me by surprise. Eventually another eastbound, this one a vehicle train, came through the OS:

BNSF 7300 East 1 - BNSF 7300 (GE ES44DC) and BNSF 7476 (GE ES44DC) make short work of making track speed with this eastbound vehicle train seen here moving through the OS at CP West DoubleA on BNSF’s Seligman Subdivision.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 7300 East 2 - BNSF 7300 (GE ES44DC) and BNSF 7476 (GE ES44DC) make short work of making track speed with this eastbound vehicle train seen here east of CP West DoubleA on BNSF’s Seligman Subdivision.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

As the sun began to hang lower in the sky it was time to find a suitable camping location. We moved a bit further west along the line and settled for a secluded spot west of CP West DoubleA.

Mossberg 500 Tactical Shotgun

This proved to be a suitable location for a little target practice and gun familiarization time having recently added a Mossberg 500 to our arsenal. So Deb and I took turns shooting a tree stump. I must say that I like my new Mossberg very much and it should serve us well here in BFE.

After setting up the rig for the night, Deb and I returned track side to caught the final few shots before the sun set entirely. Again, the deep cuts of the line presented few sight lines but so we worked with what we had: 

Into West DoubleA 1 - A solid set of GEVOs (GE ES44DCs), running elephant-style, scoot this eastbound doublestack train around a curve inside of a cut just west of CP West DoubleA as the sun sinks low in the evening sky.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

Into West DoubleA 2 - A solid set of GEVOs (GE ES44DCs), running elephant-style, scoot this eastbound doublestack train around a curve inside of a cut just west of CP West DoubleA as the sun sinks low in the evening sky.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

Into West DoubleA 3 - An eastbound doublestack train seen negotiating a curve inside of a cut just west of CP West DoubleA as the sun sinks low in the evening sky.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 7601 East 1 - BNSF 7601 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7875 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7516 (GE ES44DC), and BNSF 7289 (GE ES44DC) are the lead units providing the horsepower to this hot intermodal “Z train” just west of CP West DoubleA on the Seligman Subdivision of BNSF’s vaunted transcon route.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

BNSF 7601 East 2 - BNSF 7601 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7875 (GE ES44DC), BNSF 7516 (GE ES44DC), and BNSF 7289 (GE ES44DC) are the lead units providing the horsepower to this hot intermodal “Z train” just west of CP West DoubleA on the Seligman Subdivision of BNSF’s vaunted transcon route.
[4/21/2011 - Seligman Subdivision] © Copyright 2011, Joe Perry, ChasingSteel.com.

As I shot the trains, Deb took on the role of animal tracker and took photos of the numerous animal tracks that were all around us. Apparently there had been some recent rains to the area previously and many of the tracks were well preserved in the mud. When we returned to the camper for dinner, some star gazing, and sleep, one thing we tried to do was to identify the tracks she found. Obviously there were a lot of elk tracks but also, it appeared, that some sort of big cat was around as well. I drifted off to sleep wondering what animal preys on elk and listening to the trains echoing in the cuts below us — just after I gently tapped my Mossberg to make sure it was nearby.

In the next post I’ll cover our run to Eagle Nest, the crown jewel.

Friday
Sep032010

Convergence at Crookton

After leaving the Canyon Diablo bridge we meandered west along Interstate 40 towards Williams, Arizona. By this point it was late afternoon and the lighting was getting good. I was hoping to shoot at a location we discovered during our last trip to this area in 2006. It is a cool spot near Williams that affords a semblance of solitude and the railroad track alignment offers some great curves to accentuate the struggle trains face climbing the Arizona Divide. We dubbed this area “Scary Bear Road” because the area was remote and certainly seemed like bear country to us. (We have “friendly names” for many of our railfanning locations to help differentiate them and make them easier to remember.)

At one point along the way west we discovered that our camper’s refrigerator was not staying cold. I stopped at a truck stop to have a look at it. After opening the rear access paneling and disconnecting the camper’s battery, I saw the potential source of the failure. A 25-amp fuse was not only blown, it was also badly burnt. I went into the store at the truck and tried to find the requisite components to effect a repair. I found only 2 similiar sized fuses - a 20-amp and a 30-amp fuse.

I put the 20-amp fuses in place and reconnected the battery for a test. The fuse didn’t blow but the solder holding the end of the fuse to the glass tube melted and the fuse came apart! Bummer. Not being an electrician myself, I concluded, either rightly or wrongly, that was due to the resistance being generated by the corroded connector on the fuse holder. I used a brass brush to clean the contacts best I could and put in the 30-amp fuse. I tested it again. This time it seem to hold although I was concerned that I had used a bigger fuse than was required.

After running the refrigerator for a good 20 minutes or so to no adverse effect, I put Deb on “Smoke Duty” and asked her to watch the refrigerator access panel in her side mirror for signs of smoke as we headed west on Interstate 40 once again. I put a note on my to do list to stop somewhere and get the right fuse soon.

We eventually reached the official location of “Scary Bear Road,” which is off of Garland Prairie Road, east of Williams. As I rounded the curve and expected to find our turnoff I was sorely disappointed. Apparently in last years since we had been to this area, the US Forest Service had graded a road right through the heart of the “Scary Bear Road” area. Gone was the nondescript single-lane gravel road we knew. It was replaced my a wide and fully-graded dirt road.

We decided to give it a try nonetheless to see if we could locate our previous campsite. As we traveled down the road and tried to correlate our memories with the current surroundings, we were passed by multiple folks on quads or ATVs and many people hauling boats on trailers. It soon became apparent that this area was no longer affording a removed sense of remoteness but rather one of a busy rural route. I did not feel comfortable camping in the area so we, unfortunately, moved on. Well, at least we have our memories of “Scary Bear Road” from 2006.

Route 66 Overpass at Crookton, Arizona.

Disappointed and tired from the day’s event thus far, I decided to by-pass the Williams area entirely and try to reconnect with BNSF’s Seligman Subdivision at the subdivision’s namesake - Seligman, Arizona. Near the beautiful Ash Fork area we found an exit, Crookton Road, Exit 139, which reconnected with Route 66 and, thusly, the tracks. We had been away from the tracks at this point because in 1960, the Atchison, Topeka, & Santa Fe, part of the now BNSF, completed the Crookton-Cutoff which realigned the route between Williams Junction and Crookton, Arizona to reduce grades and curvatures in the area. The old alignment and roadbed can easily be seen from Interstate 40 which has accompanied us along our way since Williams.

Traveling west on Route 66, Crookton Road, from Interstate 40 brought us to location where the Crookton Cutoff crossed under Route 66. As we reached the overpass I slowed, as is my typical style, to look down the tracks in both directions to get see if there are any headlights on the horizon or signals which might betray a pending passing train.

There was no indication of an immediate passing train to be seen, but, being the BNSF’s transcon route, I knew it wouldn’t be long before one was hustling by. As I looked at the trackage from the overpass I was taken by the photographic quality of the location. The left side of the overpass had trackage which curved under the overpass and was baklit by the setting sun. The right side offered a straight alignment which was partly lit by the sun and passed through a cattle range.

I initially continued on passed the location and thought better of my decision. I made a u-turn and then another to reasses the possiblitites. I made up my mind. This was where I was going to make my final stand as the sun set below the horizon.

I found a safe location removed from the passing traffic on the west side of the overpass in which to park and left the engine running so that Deb could continue her present slumber in comfort with the air conditioning running. I grabbed my camera, regretably sans tripod, and made my way back to the overpass. I guess I hadn’t plan to be there long.

As I progressed back down the road I made a few test shots to assess the lighting and possbile framing of the scene. Some cattle were grazing down the embankment and I guess the sight of my long shadow cast down upon them spooked them and they began to run away, “mooing” all the way.

Shortly thereafter, I noticed smoke on the horizon in the west. Here comes one! I checked for traffic on the road and crossed to get into postion. It was an eastbound manifest train moving through West Crookton.

Had I thought to grab my tripod out of the truck I would have tried to capture the scene in HDR. The pace of the moving train would have presented a problem to HDR photogrphy, perhaps, but I have wanted to know what the challenges of photography moving trains in HDR would be so I could possibly figure out how to overcome the problems.

I set-up the camera for aperture-priority and closed the apeture as much as I could. These shots would be hand-held and manually framed. I fired off a series of shots as the train drew near.

Since I have begun to work with HDR photos, it is clearly apparent to me now, how cameras tend to fall short in capturing the scene as I see them. Sure is gives us an essence of what was but the subtle nuances in the details are often washed out and lose relevance in the final shot.

Don’t get me wrong, I like the shots I took and would consider them good, but they don’t do the scene complete justice, in my opinion.

After I got home I played with the images and was able to tonemap some into psuedo-HDR images:

BNSF 4782 West 1 - BNSF 4782 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4432 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and 2 more unidentified BNSF GE DASH 9-44CWs are on the point of this eastbound manifest train passing West Crookton, Arizona on BNSF’s transcon as the sun sinks low towards the horizon.
[8/11/2010 - Seligman Subdivision] © 2010 Joe Perry.
BNSF 4782 West 2 - BNSF 4782 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4432 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and 2 more unidentified BNSF GE DASH 9-44CWs are on the point of this eastbound manifest train passing West Crookton, Arizona on BNSF’s transcon as the sun sinks low towards the horizon.
[8/11/2010 - Seligman Subdivision] © 2010 Joe Perry.
BNSF 4782 West 3 - BNSF 4782 (GE DASH 9-44CW), BNSF 4432 (GE DASH 9-44CW), and 2 more unidentified BNSF GE DASH 9-44CWs are on the point of this eastbound manifest train passing West Crookton, Arizona on BNSF’s transcon as the sun sinks low towards the horizon.
[8/11/2010 - Seligman Subdivision] © 2010 Joe Perry.

All in all I caught four trains at this location before both, the sunlight and my energy waned. I took a parting shot and thought of the fortune that had brought me here at the right time to get some cool shots despite this was not my intended shooting location.

Sometimes the railfan gods smile upon you, I guess.

Sunset at West Crookton - The sun sinks below the horizon at West Crookton, Arizona.
[8/11/2010 - Seligman Subdivision] © 2010 Joe Perry.